Lune+Aster Eclipse Volumizing & Curling Mascara – Black – Volumizing & curling vegan tubular mascara that won’t smudge, yet removes easily with warm water

Customers find this mascara to be the best on the market, praising its effectiveness at preventing raccoon eyes and making lashes long. The product washes off easily in the shower and is smudge-resistant, with one customer noting it doesn't flake or smear. While some customers say it doesn't clump, others find it clumpy, and though it lasts a long time, some mention it starts to flake off in hours.